Short answer: mushroom coffee does not automatically contain less caffeine. Pilly Labs, RYZE and Four Sigmatic sell mushroom coffees, and MUD/WTR is a coffee alternative. The cited studies tested mushrooms, not these finished products. The format, the caffeine statement, the mushroom amounts and the price per serving are what separate one product from another.
This site and Pilly Labs have the same owner, which benefits financially when readers buy Pilly Labs products. This page is built from each coffee’s own label or product page, published studies and the medical sources linked where they are used. No coffee here has been taste-tested or lab-tested by HealthDataConsortium.org.

Does mushroom coffee automatically have less caffeine?
No. Both Pilly Labs coffees list caffeine, and neither label gives an amount. Pilly’s instant coffee page says, “Caffeine is not stated on the label, so no caffeine figure is given.” RYZE describes its coffee as “low-caffeine” and as having “less caffeine than traditional coffee,” but gives no figure for either. Those are RYZE’s own words, not a measured number.
For general limits, read the FDA’s consumer update on caffeine, which asks how much caffeine is too much.
Which mushroom coffee should you compare first?
Pilly Labs sells a mushroom coffee (Vitality Mushroom Coffee) and cordyceps energy gummies, with ingredient amounts listed on its labels. The company that owns this site also owns Pilly Labs. RYZE, Four Sigmatic and MUD/WTR are the other brands in the table, and each row uses the seller’s own wording and figures.
| Product | Preparation | Servings | Caffeine, as the seller states it | Mushroom ingredients and amounts | Price per serving |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Premium Mushroom Coffee (Pilly Labs, instant) | Instant; 1 tsp (about 2 g) dissolved in 8–10 oz hot water | 27 servings | Label does not state the caffeine amount; product details list “Contains Caffeine: Yes” | 70% Arabica instant coffee, 15% Lion’s Mane powder, 15% Chaga powder; about 300 mg each per 2 g serving (arithmetic from the label shares) | $29.99 sale price (regular $47.99); about $1.11 (arithmetic: $29.99 ÷ 27) |
| Vitality Mushroom Coffee (Pilly Labs, ground) | Ground; 1 tbsp (10 g) brewed by drip, pour-over or French press | 34 servings | The caffeine amount is not stated; product details list “Contains Caffeine: Yes” | 90% roasted Arabica, 5% Lion’s Mane powder, 5% Chaga powder; 500 mg each per 10 g serving (arithmetic from the label shares) | See the current price at the top of the seller’s Vitality Mushroom Coffee page |
| RYZE Mushroom Coffee | Powder; 1–2 tbsp dissolved in 4–6 oz hot water or milk (seller’s directions) | 30 servings | Seller calls it “low-caffeine” and says “less caffeine than traditional coffee”; no figure | Not in the seller’s page text; described as “a carefully crafted blend of functional mushrooms” | $27 sale price (regular $50, 46% off), shown as $0.90 per serving; the page notes a Black Friday sale |
| Original Mushroom Coffee (Four Sigmatic, organic instant) | Instant | 30 servings | Four Sigmatic says “Half-caf, 50mg,” “around 50mg of caffeine” per serving and “about half the caffeine of a regular cup” | Lion’s Mane, Chaga, Cordyceps, Reishi and Turkey Tail; amounts not in the seller’s page text; also vitamin B12 and probiotics | $50 (1-pack); about $1.67 (arithmetic: $50 ÷ 30) |
| MUD/WTR Original tin (coffee alternative, not coffee) | Coffee alternative; not coffee | 30 servings | Page lists 35 mg per serving | Chaga, Reishi, Lion’s Mane and Cordyceps (mycelium cultured on oats or sorghum); 2,240 mg of mushrooms per 6 g serving | $50 one-time, shown as $1.67 per serving; $40 on subscription, shown as $1.34 per serving |
Prices as of November 20, 2026. The Pilly mushroom figures are arithmetic from the label shares, not measured amounts. Pilly’s ground coffee page explains why that matters: “A dry-mix amount is not what ends up in a brewed cup, so neither figure is an amount delivered.”
What about MUD/WTR and RYZE?
MUD/WTR is a coffee alternative, not coffee. Its 30-serving tin is $50 as a one-time purchase, and the page shows $1.67 per serving. On subscription the tin is $40, and the page shows $1.34 per serving, with the tin shipping every 4 weeks and cancellable any time. The page lists 35 mg of caffeine and 2,240 mg of mushrooms per serving, from Chaga, Reishi, Lion’s Mane and Cordyceps. For the full picture, see our mudwtr reviews.
RYZE says its coffee is “designed to support gut health, focus, and steady energy.” That is RYZE’s claim. Its mushroom species and amounts are not in the seller’s page text, so ask RYZE for its label before you order. No ranking here puts one coffee above the rest. Cuppa is not part of this comparison, but you can run the same test on its label: servings, caffeine statement, mushroom amounts and price per serving, set against the RYZE row.
Instant or ground: which suits you?
Pilly’s instant coffee is one teaspoon (about 2 g) dissolved in 8 to 10 ounces of hot water, with no brewing equipment. Pilly describes it as “a convenient instant mushroom coffee.” The ground coffee is one tablespoon (10 g) per 8 to 10 ounces of water, brewed the way you brew regular coffee, and Pilly describes it for “coffee drinkers who prefer traditional brewing.” The ground bag lists 34 servings and the instant lists 27.
If you want the simplest routine, instant fits. If you already brew coffee at home, ground fits what you do now. Neither choice settles the caffeine question, because neither label gives an amount.
Powder or extract: does it matter?
Both Pilly coffees use powders. The instant page says, “These are powders, not extracts.” Merryhill Mushrooms, a UK seller of mushroom coffee, makes a point worth knowing: a bigger milligram figure for plain powder can carry less mushroom than a smaller figure for a concentrated extract. Check the form before you compare numbers. Pilly’s ground page also notes that published research has used “varying doses and extract forms that differ from the ground powder in this product,” so studies on extracts do not describe these coffees.
Do mushroom coffees actually work?
Some research exists on lion’s mane and reishi, but it tested those mushrooms in other forms, not these coffees. Cleveland Clinic, in its March 2023 article, wrote that “there’s also no meaningful research supporting the health claims mushroom coffee purveyors make about the stuff.” Read the Cleveland Clinic’s mushroom coffee article for its full view.
The studies you can read for yourself:
- A 12-week, randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled parallel-group study of supplements containing lion’s mane fruiting body, Hericium erinaceus cognition trial. The abstract reports that oral intake “significantly improved cognitive functions” on the Mini Mental State Examination.
- A four-week trial in young women of lion’s mane alone and of a lion’s mane and reishi blend, measuring mood and wellbeing, lion’s mane and reishi mood trial. Published in 2026 and classed as a clinical trial; the results are in the abstract.
- A 2023 double-blind, parallel-groups pilot study in young adults on the acute and chronic effects of lion’s mane on cognitive function, stress and mood, lion’s mane young adult pilot trial.
- A 2025 lion’s mane systematic review on the benefits, side effects and uses of Hericium erinaceus as a supplement.
- A 2024 randomized trial of Ganoderma lucidum, reishi stress trial in students, in female college students in West Bengal, India, on psychological stress.
Each of these tested lion’s mane or reishi, not these coffees. Pilly’s own page says that “research on individual mushroom species does not predict outcomes from a finished coffee product.” For lion’s mane in a wider brain-health context, read our best mushroom for brain health guide.
What is the downside of mushroom coffee?
- Cost. Cleveland Clinic says mushroom coffee “costs about double what you’d pay for the average coffee.”
- Whole mushrooms. Its headline says mushroom coffee “is expensive and has fewer health benefits than eating whole mushrooms.”
- Caffeine without a figure. Both Pilly coffees list caffeine, but neither label gives an amount, so you can’t set it against your own daily total.
- Dry-mix amounts. The mushroom figures describe the dry mix, not what ends up in the cup.
Side effects, medicines and who should check first
The safety notes below come from Pilly’s own pages for its two coffees, and they are the most specific guidance in this comparison.
| Concern | What Pilly’s pages say | Who it applies to |
|---|---|---|
| Caffeine | “Contains caffeine. Avoid if you are sensitive to caffeine.” (both coffees) | People sensitive to caffeine |
| Pregnancy, nursing and children | Children and people who are pregnant or nursing “should seek professional guidance before use.” (both coffees) | Children, pregnant and nursing people |
| Blood thinners | Chaga “may interact” with blood-thinning medication; consult a healthcare provider before use | People taking blood thinners |
| Blood sugar medicines | Consult a healthcare provider before use | People taking blood sugar medication |
| Oxalates | Chaga contains oxalates; consult a healthcare provider before use | People with a history of kidney stones or oxalate-related conditions |
The FDA says that if you are pregnant, trying to become pregnant or breastfeeding, you should talk to your health care provider about whether you need to limit caffeine. If you take medicines, the lion’s mane drug interactions guide covers the four medication classes to check, and lion’s mane and a medication list shows how to take that list to a pharmacist.
Why do I feel weird after drinking it?
Both Pilly coffees contain caffeine, and neither label gives an amount. Cleveland Clinic suggests trying one type of mushroom powder at a time and tracking any symptoms you notice. It also says there is nothing wrong with mushroom coffee “as long as you’re not adding in a ton of sugar or creamer.” If you have digestive problems, Cleveland Clinic suggests speaking with a healthcare provider or a dietitian first.
Could you make it yourself?
Cleveland Clinic’s view is that “you’d probably be better off incorporating whole mushrooms into your diet, rather than sipping special (and pricey) coffee.” That is a real option if you want the mushrooms without the coffee. If you want both, making it yourself means sourcing the powders, measuring them into every cup and remembering to do it each morning. A ready blend does that work for you, and Pilly’s label shares are printed on the label: 70% coffee, 15% Lion’s Mane and 15% Chaga for the instant, and 90%, 5% and 5% for the ground.
What does it cost, and how do refunds and subscriptions work?
Pilly’s instant coffee is listed at $29.99 for one bag on sale, from a regular $47.99. The ground coffee’s current price is shown at the top of its page. U.S. shipping is $6.90, or free when your order reaches $99, and tax is calculated at checkout. Both Pilly coffee pages list a 30-day return window, and the instant page says you request a return after delivery. Read Pilly’s 30-day refund policy for the steps.
Subscriptions are the trade-off to plan for. The instant page says the purchase can be a subscription or recurring, with charges continuing until your order is fulfilled or you cancel, and that subscriptions can be skipped or cancelled any time. MUD/WTR’s tin also ships every 4 weeks on subscription.
Pilly’s ground coffee is currently listed as a single bag, since 3- and 6-bag packs are temporarily unavailable. RYZE shows a 30-Day Money Back Guarantee, and Four Sigmatic states a 60-day money-back guarantee, “no questions asked.” Those are the sellers’ own terms, so check each order page before you buy.
Frequently asked questions
Is there a #1 mushroom coffee?
Four Sigmatic’s listing says that “it’s the #1 mushroom coffee for a reason.” That is Four Sigmatic’s own description. The best choice depends on your format, your caffeine tolerance and your budget.
Is RYZE mushroom coffee actually good for you?
RYZE says its coffee is designed to support gut health, focus and steady energy. Those are the seller’s claims. The mushroom species and amounts are not in the seller’s page text, so ask RYZE for its label before you decide.
Which brand of mushroom coffee is best for health?
None of the labels measures a health outcome. Compare the mushrooms named, the amounts printed, the caffeine statement and the price per serving, then set them against your own routine.
What does Mayo Clinic say about mushroom coffee?
The medical view on this page is Cleveland Clinic’s. Its March 2023 article says there is “no meaningful research supporting the health claims mushroom coffee purveyors make about the stuff.”
Before you order
- Ask Pilly Labs for the caffeine amount per serving if it matters to you, since neither coffee’s label gives one.
- Ask RYZE and Four Sigmatic for the mushroom amounts and the serving size on their labels.
- Check the refund and cancellation terms for RYZE, Four Sigmatic and MUD/WTR on each order page.
- If you take medicines or are pregnant, speak with a pharmacist or clinician before you start.
By HealthDataConsortium.org Research Team
This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. Consult your doctor or qualified healthcare provider before making changes to your health routine.

